06 December 2012 A Conservation Icon in the Crosshairs Posted by: Jamie Rappaport Clark | 94 comments | Share: Gray wolf in Yellowstone National Park (Credit: Sandy Sisti) Jamie Rappaport Clark, President and CEO I am an incredibly lucky biologist. Every year I am privileged to join dozens of Defenders of Wildlife friends and their families in Yellowstone National Park. Our mission: to watch wolves! My husband Jim, my son Carson and I look forward to this trip every year as we monitor wolf recovery and see firsthand the amazing rebound of a species on the brink of extinction in the lower 48. One of the highlights of the trip is to get some time with some of the wolf biologists that are on the ground studying wolves all year long. Doug Smith, Dan Stahler, Erin Albers, and others do a fantastic job tracking about a dozen packs throughout the park. The research they have been doing for the past 17 years has been invaluable to wolf conservation and behavior studies worldwide. That’s why it is so disturbing to see some of these very same wolves gunned down during the current hunting season. Unfortunately, wolves don’t understand borders and many of the park wolves are used to seeing people. They don’t know that it’s another world outside of the park boundaries, or that people could mean danger outside the park. Already, ten Yellowstone wolves have been killed; seven of them with radio research collars, possibly putting decades of wolf research in jeopardy. We learn so much from Yellowstone research that helps us better understand and manage wolves, not only in Yellowstone but throughout the Northern Rockies and everywhere wolves now find a home. One of the most important research efforts is on predator-prey relationships. We now better understand what types of species wolves prey on, how much they eat, how they work as a pack and what animals rely on the remains of those kills for their own survival. The research also shows us how other animals behave in the presence of wolves. Further research indicates that wolves impact numerous species, a term some biologists refer to as “trophic cascades.” One theory is that wolves may influence elk behavior and cause them to spend less time browsing the valley and streams of Yellowstone. This has allowed willows and other trees and brush to flourish, providing richer habitat for beaver, fish, birds and amphibians. We might never have known all of the impressive and important roles that wolves play if we had not had data from the years of extensive research on Yellowstone wolves. A collared gray wolf in Yellowstone. Photo courtesy of William C. Campbell/U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service. Other research provides data on disease, genetics, breeding, kill rates, pup survival and mortality. Yellowstone is considered by scientists world-wide to be the premier landscape for wolf research because of how visible the wolves are in Yellowstone’s northern range. In addition to the tragedy of these iconic wolves being killed, we are losing a plethora of research with the loss of each collared Yellowstone wolf. Yellowstone wolves are valuable for the data they generate that help us understand more about wolves and the important role they play in the ecosystem. But they are also important to people. During the first years of wolf reintroduction, biologists had no idea that the newly-released wolves in the northern range of Yellowstone would be so visible to researchers and to the many visitors who visit the park every year. Tens of thousands of people are lucky enough to come to Yellowstone every year to watch the wolves that make this great park their home. I know many photographers and filmmakers that have made their living following the wolf packs and capturing their personalities and behaviors; tour guides also benefit from the desire of tourists to see wolves. And all of these people spend money in the park and in the local communities — on the order of $35 million annually, and leveraging a total economic impact of about $70 million per year. Photo by Michael Quinton/National Geograhic Stock. The killing of these Yellowstone wolves certainly brings the management policies of Wyoming, Idaho and Montana into clear focus. The loss of these wolves — the most protected in the region, until they set foot outside Yellowstone National Park — provides a window into what is happening to wolves throughout the Northern Rockies, where wolves have few and in some cases no protections. Already, 257 wolves have been killed so far this hunting season, and more than 800 have died since Congress removed federal protections for wolves in the core of the Rockies. It’s hard to believe that this is an animal that only last year was protected as an endangered species. The states of Montana, Idaho and Wyoming need to step up and work with the park officials to reduce these serious impacts on wolf research efforts. America has a lot invested in this research and in these wolves. We should be proud that we are leaders in wolf conservation research and take steps now to avoid the losses that occurred this year. We cannot let one of the most spectacular conservation accomplishments of the last century be undermined by wrong-headed management practices. It’s time we all take a stand and let the states surrounding Yellowstone know that their actions are unacceptable, and we need to work together to ensure a brighter future not only for the wolves in Yellowstone but for those throughout the region. 94 Responses to “A Conservation Icon in the Crosshairs” « Older Comments Miroslav December 8th, 2012 Dear wolf friends, as a biologist from far away, Serbia in Europe, I support your wolf conservation activities. Unfortunately, we also have wolves always accused of any damage although many stray dogs kill livestock. Hunters and locals have a centuries old tradition that wolves nust be shot. Fortunately, for many years arsenic poisoning is forbidden but i previous times, besides wolves, killed and exterminated many birds of prey. There is some improvement in public attitudes towards wolves, even among hunters but their aim is in protecting them at a minimum level so as to earn money from wolves shot for trophies. Every winter in many places, hunters organiye wolf chases. I wish You luck in the battle for the wolf especially in the magnificent Yellowstone National Park which I had a chance to visit as a boy in 1959. Jon December 8th, 2012 Why don’t we just shoot any animal that moves? I know people who do. I’m not ALLOWED TO SHOOT THEM FOR SOME REASON! Not that I would. Why is it so damned acceptable to trap for fur? Why are people not responsible for their pets? I am getting pretty pissed off with killing all our wonderful animals. I used to hunt…my bad….I am older now and ashamed that I didn’t get it then. Just look an animal in the eyes and tell yourself there isn’t a good reason they are on this earth. I guess the hunters are not watching these posts….I hope the politicians are. Sad times we live in. Do we have to kill everything? Millie Sheen December 8th, 2012 10 Innocent wolves gone… when will people understand we Have to STOP! You do an amazing job defenders. Thank you from me and all the wolves. Millie Sheen December 8th, 2012 Sorry, I am mistaken there was only 257 killed in 1 hunting season!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! PEOPLE JUST STOP KILLING THE CREATURES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THEY ARE NEVER COMING BACK. THEY MAY BE BEAUTIFUL BUT THE FUR LOOKS MUCH BETTER ON THE ANIMAL THAN ON YOUR WALL OR FLOOR!!!!!!!!!!!! Just leave them alone!!!!! Millie Sheen December 8th, 2012 No animal should be killed at all! All of them have a right to live! Millie Sheen December 8th, 2012 I totally agree with you. We kill for fun and we have no right to do that! Millie Sheen December 8th, 2012 It upsets me too. When I heard about the Washington pack I think it was go extinct I was in tears we have no right to kill innocent creatures! Millie Sheen December 8th, 2012 I see what you are saying and ranchers can and will have to learn to deal with them but don’t take it out on the researchers. it isn’t their fault some people kill for fun. And they do their best to stop it. Gerard Vath December 8th, 2012 Susan, It is greed, arrogance and mostly a “BLOODLUST” !! federico December 8th, 2012 Che tristezza!! Debra Perry December 8th, 2012 These wolves were killed wearing their transmitter collars? I think these “hunters” violated the main principal of a experienced/trained hunter – first principal, have a clear view of your target! If this had been adhered to, not one of these wolves should have been killed! Go back to hunter’s safety 101! UNLESS you were blatantly targeting this pack! Shameful! Karl Landl December 8th, 2012 I’m having second thoughts about ever to return to Jackson Hole, WY to ski again. Went many times and friends of mine are currently planning on a trip but I declined to come along for obvious reasons. Did not know that the state has so many sick people or so called sportsmen/hunters hiding behind trees to blast these poor wolves apart. GREAT HEROS!!! Jingli December 8th, 2012 Hunting should be outlawed, regardless whether the animal if collared or not! All men who shoot helpless animals are plain COWARDS. Eric December 8th, 2012 I agree with Nikki. The Yellowstone wolf re-introduction program has been a spectacular success, what a turn around in perception of this animal since just the days of Aldo Leopold, not all that long ago. Ironically though, the greater the success the more some kind of hunt is likely to be outside the protected area. I agree that if radio-collared wolves can be spared they should be, its a huge waste of research dollars and effort. But the article should do more to address this reality: Yellowstone is going to be constantly producing more wolves, every year new wolves will be born. In certain circumstances, like if disease spreads through the park, or there are massive forest fires, more wolves may die of natural causes than are born, but wolves are resourceful, and in a typical year more will be born than die. Wolves are highly territorial, some of the new wolves when “adolescent” in age could join other packs but many will be floaters for a time, chased from territory to territory. Inevitably some will leave the Park. Now what? Let them establish new packs, and let the wolf production phenomenon continue to spread across the West? This issue of population growth, strict “rules” among wolves of pack membership and size, and inevitable long-distance dispersal of young wolves across today’s West, a profoundly human-dominated landscape, needs to be confronted. I see not a single comment on this page recognizing these long-term challenges. In Liz December 8th, 2012 By over reproducing we are not only killing the environment we are killing our selves. If you won’t consider slowing the human birth rate for the animals, do it for the children. Colleen December 8th, 2012 I am so proud to be a supporter of Defenders of Wildlife. Thank you for ALL you do, not only to actively protect wildlife species, but also to inform and educate us all. Sherri Gilbert December 8th, 2012 I can’t believe people ate this ignorant about the ecosystem. Killing off any predators will have consequences. But I guess hanging that beautiful wolf head on your den wall os more important!!! Jeannie December 8th, 2012 Folks, suggest you read “The World Peace Diet,” by Dr Will Tuttle…How can anyone with kids and grandkids not want to protect our wildlife, nature and all living creatures? I pray there is a “tipping point” before it is too late for all of the world’s magnificent animals and for ourselves. How much pleasure can it really bring to anyone to easily slaughter the wolves, the coyotes, or any of our plante’s animals? There is no defense! Where is our global consciousness? We are slaughtering each other as well, as usual, in the name of religion (religious and cultural intolerance). Surely it is not a joke that our deepest prayers must be for peace and tolerance, ethics and integrity, so that those who come after us inherit a better world. Laurie December 8th, 2012 We have to demand a full investigation of these killings–now at eight. Hunters are targeting collared animals. They may be able to track them with radio receivers. The people doing this are terrorizing a public-funded research program. We have to ask our federal representatives to place a moratorium on hunting of wolves in the states surrounding Yellowstone, and then investigate the homegrown terrorism that is attacking the people’s land and wildlife. Marlene December 8th, 2012 Very nicely said. Seems the focus is currently on eliminating wild horses (BLM – for the greedy cattle ranchers to have all the land) and the wolves. Seems we “humans” think we can play God. To paraphrase a native american saying (another factor we seem to have worked to eliminate) – “the land was not given to us by our parents – it was loaned to us by our children”. Kathie Jenni December 8th, 2012 Thank you, bonellen; I couldn’t agree more. It’s very hard for me to support reintroduction into these states where barbaric attitudes are prevalent in many regions. (And I’m a native Montanan, so ashamed to see these heartbreaking stories of outrage.) I think you make an incredibly strong point. I so appreciate reading all of these comments from people who “get” basic compassion and the right to live. Thanks to all of you. Barbara Kates December 9th, 2012 The NY Times story literally brought me to tears. The killing of both the alpha female and male mate is beyond outrageous, given their collars and markings clearly were recognized throughout the area. It is no longer paranoid to state the obvious: Hunters are targeting the Yellowstone packs we have worked to hard to preserve and bring back to healthy numbers. Please consider a major campaign alliance with the NPCA, National Park Foundation, Yellowstone Park groups, as well as the usual animal protection organizations. This is an assault, pure and simple, on the national park wildlife. I will send a donation to match my words. Keep me posted. Sincerely, Barbara Kates This frankly sounds Deb Kulcsar December 9th, 2012 Thank you for your work, Defenders! My plea: Hunters and guides and MT/WY govt: please do not target collared wolves. This appears to be especially intentional. Ingrid December 10th, 2012 Jim, if you haven’t yet read it, “The World Peace Diet” by Will Tuttle is great on this topic. For people who care about wolves, predators and other wildlife, one of the best things we can do is say ‘no’ to the livestock industry which is behind so much predator extermination (often through USDA Wildlife Services). There’s quite a bit of information, too, on how ranging cattle destroy riparian habitats and contribute to species loss, often subsidized by us since they’re grazing on public land. Hyde December 10th, 2012 Because they were shot/trapped 900 miles outside of Yellowstone. They are a roaming animal. They go where they are unwelcome. Such as towns and farms/ranches. They were killed legally. Maybe you can all save your money and build a nice pretty fence around Yellowstone Hyde December 10th, 2012 They were harvested legally … Gregg Drozda December 11th, 2012 I would urge that any and all national country recording artists, such as Lady Antebellum, Rascal Flats, Dwight Yoakum, Toby Keith, Jason Aldean and Luke Bryan immediately withdraw from their scheduled performances at the 2013 Cheyenne Frontier Days and any other future concert in the state of Wyoming. Ashley Judd is on the Board of Defenders. She should use her connections with Nashville to “blacklist” Wyoming and prevent that state from benefitting economically from A-List concerts while the Yellowstone wolf packs are being slaughtered for the thrill of the killers out to make a “trophy” fur rug or wall hanging. Killing well known COLLARED Yellowstone wolves ought to be a criminal offense. These packs DO NOT BELONG TO WYOMING! They belong to the National Park System and to the People of the United States. PLEASE JOIN ME IN SUPPORT OF BOYCOTTING ANY AND EVERY EVENT THAT BRINGS ECONOMIC BENEFIT TO THE STATE OF WYOMING. THAT INCLUDES CHEYENNE FRONTIER DAYS AND CFD COUNTRY MUSIC CONCERTS. Pia Gismondi December 11th, 2012 The news of the latest slaughter of these “ambassador” wolves is truly devastating as well as sickening. It would appear that those involved in these killings do not consider anything other than the fact they have been given licence to hunt and kill an animal at no matter what cost. Here in the UK, I have seen some of the documentaries showing the sheer hatred that hunters and ranchers have for the wolf in particular. It is truly worrying that humans can have such vehement feelings, to the extent that a species of animal risks eradication. Can these people be educated and will they be prepared to work with and listen to conservationists? We can only hope,give our support to organisations like Defenders of Wildlife, and keep fighting. I work with socialised wolves at Paradise Wildlife Park in the UK, and am always mentioning Defenders of Wildlife and the plight of wolves in the States, especially at the moment. Keep up the good work. Nancy Grimes December 11th, 2012 Every person who has been to Yellowstone and ‘happened’ upon a scene of wolves playing with each other, eating at a carcass, or bounding over the hills has one of the most spectacular visual experiences of their life–later, it turns inexplicably into a personal experience that is carried with that person their whole life: this memory of wolves can be brought to mind at any time. It excites our imagination, brings closer the beauty of nature, and we revisit that ‘wild’ part of our selves that civilization so mindlessly has stamped out of us. This is what happened last summer when a young teenage couple saw through the viewing scope a pack of wolves around a carcass in the Lamar Valley. When they witnessed a grizzly lumbering out of the nearby forest, boldly charge at the wolf pack, then race for their kill, they couldn’t believe their eyes and may never see this scene again… but they have it in their memory, never to be lost. This is what these farming hunters need to feel and experience. This cannot be driven home to them by those of us who love our natural world. They have to come upon it quite by accident, when their defenses are down, and they feel for the first time what wild wolves and grizzlies are all about. Diane C Abbysinian December 11th, 2012 Absolutely despicable and abhorrent! I will never enter that state ever, what in GOD’s name is wrong with these gun-wielding psychopaths?? Karma will handle it in the end…for those sick freaks! Hunter December 11th, 2012 Being an avid hunter myself, with the bonus of having a Ph.D. in wildlife biology, I would ask you to seek your information from peer-reviewed sources free of bias and opinion. Hunting, not wolf watching, is the single largest driving force (both monetarily and through the ecosystem service it provides) for the conservation of wildlife in the U.S., including wolves. I assure you, the wolf quota is monitored very closely, and their populations will continue to thrive. I would wager that most hunters have a deeper connection with nature than you can imagine, and aren’t out to mindlessly slaughter animals as you portray. We all want wolves around, but sustainable harvest will do the species good…the data support this. Cheryl Calliari December 12th, 2012 This morning on NPR I heard about the death of Yellowstone’s Alpha Female wolf #832. I mourn her hunting death and I regret every time I ignored a request from Defenders to take action. Never again will I not act when requested to do so by Defenders. Your work is essential and I treasure every wolf that you save. Doug December 12th, 2012 Dear Hunter, So, you believe that eradication of the wolves is very unlikely with the current events taking place? What happened to the mountain lion and wolves in other states could happen to the wolves of the Northern Rockies if we are not pro-actively managing them. The carcasses of white-tail deer on the roads of Texas and Washington and Ohio at this time of year tell me that the predator-prey equilibrium was lost a long time ago with the loss of predators like cougars and wolves, killed by hunters. And that hunters today are not plentiful enough to reduce the deer population so that it is healthy and not a threat to automobile drivers who kill them. It doesn’t take a wildlife biologist to know that wolf slaughter in the United States, including the Rocky Mountain region and Wisconsin or Minnesota is ill-conceived and just plain wrong. I am a biologist too if that matters. Jon December 14th, 2012 Mr. Hunter, So the way you show your appreciation for wildlife is to shoot it? Explain to me how this shows that you love wildlife. Your reaction is: “Oh, what a beautiful animal. How I would love to kill it.” ??? Dolores Hayes December 21st, 2012 Hunter: What a CROCK! Your lame rationalization for killing wolves holds no water at all. Anyone who says that a species can be “managed” by killing half of its members is either a moron or a liar. Which are YOU? If you really want to shoot a dangerous animal, pick on wild dogs, who take far more livestock AND who, unlike wolves, WILL attack humans! Admit it: you just want a bunch of wolf pelts to other like you will mistake you for a real man. You are not. @Greg Drozda: EXCELLENT idea, but good luck getting many of these people to anger their fan base! Toby Keith, for instance, showed up on Stephen Colbert’s Christmas Special toting a semi-automatic weapon! Colbert may have thought Keith was joking; I don’t! We need stuff like what you suggested, but more so: strict fines and even jail time for those taking the lives of these magnificent animals–especially the collared ones! JACK KURTZHALTS December 21st, 2012 I CANNOT GRASP THIS CONCEPT OF INDISCRIMINANT KILLING OF A SPECIES THAT CONTRIBUTES MORE TO WILDLIFE HEALTH & BALANCE THAN IT PREY’S UPON! I POSE THE QUESTION: HOW DID WILDLIFE SURVIVE BEFORE “MAN” GOT INVOLVED….THINKING he KNOWS BEST! A “REAL” SPORTSMAN/HUNTER/MAN KNOWS BETTER,….THE REST ARE FOOLISH IMPOSTERS! THIS IS HOW I HAVE LONG VIEWED THIS MAN VS. WILDLIFE SCENARIO! Jeremy December 21st, 2012 Just watch the New about Yellowstone National Park It sad to me that we are now kill Wolf.. i hear from my grandma that Obama said now we can kill them b.c there more of them now. I think it bullshit what did they do to you. So i set here and ask how can i help Donna Backes December 22nd, 2012 Some of you may know the story of a wolf named ROMEO in Alaska.He would come around and follow people walking, not in a threating way but wanting to play with the.dogs that came with there owners.He made the news and the Alaska magazine .I.was blessed to see this beautiful black wolf with gold.eyes. Seeing him was the highlight. of my trip.To see a wild animal wanting to trust humans.Which most want to kill.One man was blessed to have this wolf trust him. He only came at certain times of the year. Why we will never know. I went back to Alaska hoping to.see.him and I found out 2 idiots had shot him.and mounted. I attended the memorial for him and there were people of all kinds.Fish and game, police and hunters. Some hunters had tears in there eyes.This lone black wolf who never harmed anyone came into our lives to show us there can be peace and trust. He also show us the gentle silly.side of himself. Than hey are the monsters they are made out to be.I am so.thankful to have had the chance to see this most special animal. The two idiots that killed him.destroyed that. WAKE UP PEOPLE….. Let us not destroy everything. With his gentle playing with peoples. pets and coming back every year.His trust got him killed.PLEASE LET US STOP KILLING THESE BEAUTIFUL ANIMALS. There is only less.than half percent dna difference between them and your own dog. ROMEO I hope your a bright star in the heavens. May one day we can coexist with each other.I have been blessed to have a wolf let me into his life. He is my fourth.I.trust him more than I do most humans. Please let us all try to be.good to our fellow creatures and humans. Derek December 27th, 2012 This is wrong why cant they just leave these poor creatures alone…I cant wait to start my revolt because the people who hunt them will have to shoot me first. and obama oh he will hear from me alright. Millie Sheen January 2nd, 2013 I think it is absolutely terrible what us as humans do to the planets other creatures. But I mean of course if they are around humans that don’t do them any harm they are going to trust the hunters too. In my opinion we should protect more wolves. Or. As I have said before why don’t the hunters LEAVE THEM ALONE!!! Arleen Judd January 9th, 2013 Do we have a chance of saving these beautiful animals? I’m beginning to think we don’t because of the heartless killings that are happening. Obama will cut the important things like wildlife and allow the years of welfare fraud. I get very upset and will send a donation. I just wish the government services and states would see what a waste of life, which isn’t of any benefit to anything is causing! Sincerely, Arleen J. Alice C February 13th, 2013 i completely agree! im only 13 but i have tried ultipule things to save any type of animal. i hate hunters, there no point in killing them unless they have to big of a population. Robert June 28th, 2013 Actually they arnt just killed. Usually the skins are taken but unfortunately the meat is wasted. Im a hunter and when i kill something i use every part of the animal down to the bone. So most of ya’ll say hunters are murderers when most of us provide more money and effort towards game and non game animals than the average public. And you guys are no less killers when you step on a roach or flush a spider down the drain, which i personally try to not do as often as possible because it provides no benefit for me or the bug, so get off your high horse and think before you speak. I love wolves, just as much as i love every animal on this planet. But of course im a “bloodthirsty” hunter. Dawn Welch June 28th, 2013 Laurie, I agree 100% with you. These are hate crimes against animals, and not necessary killings. « Older Comments Post Your Comment Click here to cancel reply. Name (required) Mail (required) (will not be published) You May also be interested in Wolf Weekly Wrap-Up Helicopter gunning kills 23 wolves in Idaho; Urge Secretary Jewell to abandon gray wolf delisting proposal — Call your representative by March 14; Washington wildlife agency urged to end support for abolishing federal wolf protections; The latest on Governor Otter’s wolf control board. Two Too Many Development Projects in the Ivanpah Valley While these projects most definitely directly impact a species that has been identified as threatened and is dependent on the habitat where they would be built, Silver State South and Stateline’s approval is most troubling for a bigger reason. You see, this isn’t just an issue for the Ivanpah Valley. Developers and agencies need to be conscious of how and where they plan energy projects all across the country. They need to look at renewable energy planning with a landscape-wide lens, understanding that building in the right places and making an effort to minimize environmental impacts from the start are essential. California’s Rim Fire: Opportunities Rise from the Ashes After California’s devastating Rim Fire, will officials take the opportunity to give nature a chance to fully recover?