17 July 2013 A Smarter Paradigm: Preventing Livestock Conflict in Wolf Country Posted by: Suzanne Asha Stone | 13 comments | Share: Suzanne Stone, Northern Rockies Representative The restoration of gray wolves is one of the most ecologically successful, politically controversial and socially polarized wildlife recovery efforts ever undertaken. More than 1,600 wolves have been killed in the U.S. northern Rockies in attempts to address losses of nearly 5,000 livestock and perceived threats to hunting opportunities over the last quarter century. Tragically, most of these losses could have been avoided if agencies and livestock managers were willing to try a different way. The fladry relay helped teach the worshop participants how to set up and take down fladry lines quickly. Using a model called the Wood River Wolf Project, our team is effectively demonstrating the use of nonlethal deterrents that allow livestock and wolves to coexist. Last year, ranchers grazed 27,305 sheep in our 1,200-square-mile project area from July 1 – Oct. 15. During that time, we lost only four sheep to wolves in one incident — a record not only in our state, but in our region. We also documented three wolf packs in our project area using remote motion-sensitive cameras, and no wolves were killed in the project area as a result of livestock depredation conflicts. Given the success of our model, we decided it was time to share our techniques and strategies. In June, Defenders of Wildlife hosted the Wood River Wolf Project training workshop and field demonstration in Blaine County, Idaho. The workshop covered a wide range of nonlethal tools (e.g. fladry, lighting, noise, livestock guarding dogs) and techniques (e.g. carcass removal, increased human presence, grazing route rotations) successfully used to deter wolves and other predators from killing livestock that have been used during the first five years of this model project. The classroom activities were followed by a fladry relay where the participants learned how to properly install fladry lines and parameters (see video here). The second day, led by our project field manager Patrick Graham, we met with herders out in the field as they were watching bands of sheep graze on the hillsides. They spoke about the challenges of herding thousands of sheep in rugged mountain country with abundant wild predators. They also talked about the importance of the partnership with the Wood River Wolf Project team and how much they appreciated their help in protecting the sheep using the nonlethal methods to avoid losses to wolves. The workshop included presentations by our project leaders, wildlife biologists and more. Workshop leaders included researchers and wildlife managers from the National Wildlife Research Center, Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife, project mentor Carter Niemeyer, Faulkner and Lava Lake Livestock sheep managers, and Defenders’ field contractors and staff from Idaho and Montana. Participants came from all over the country and the world! More than 50 people attended the workshop including state and tribal representatives from Washington State, Oregon, Utah, Montana, Florida and California. Our online participants included wildlife scientists and managers from all over the world including Africa, Australia, Brazil, Canada, Costa Rica, Europe, Israel, and Iran. Sadly, while our field team is working with cooperating ranchers in the west side of the valley, a rancher who has recently adopted a hands off range lambing approach is losing sheep to wolves and other predators on the east side. These losses would be preventable if he chose to use safer lambing methods where the sheep would be better protected during their vulnerable lambing time. In reaction to the sheep losses to predators, the federal Wildlife Services agent has killed multiple wolves, including three young eight-week-old wolf pups. It now looks like he is exterminating the whole pack, which is the second pack to fall victim to this tragic situation. We have offered many times to help this rancher switch to a better method for lambing and will continue to offer him help in the future with the hope that he will eventually tire of the needless loss of his sheep and the increasing public animosity toward him. It is just sad that so many animals are needlessly dying now and yet, it is indicative of our country’s archaic predator control traditions. Range riders are an important part of the Wood River Wolf project, spending most of their time in the field with the livestock. It is my greatest career goal in my lifetime to help improve the way that our nation and others manage wildlife. Humans are taking over more of the planet leaving less and less places for nature. Given the resulting loss of species across the globe, and what we know now about the important role of predators in sustaining a healthy natural environment, we cannot afford to kill wild animals just because they are considered a nuisance. It’s time to transform the archaic mindsets for a new paradigm of smarter, more effective and more humane predator management. And given the overwhelming response to our workshop, and similar efforts of others across the globe, it is clear that our shared vision and voices are growing stronger. The actions we all take now will determine the fate of these species that require human tolerance to survive. “We need another and a wiser and perhaps a more mystical concept of animals… We patronize them for their incompleteness, for their tragic fate of having taken form so far below ourselves. And therein we err, and greatly err. For the animal shall not be measured by man. In a world older and more complete than ours they move finished and complete, gifted with extensions of the senses we have lost or never attained, living by voices we shall never hear. They are not brethren, they are not underlings; they are other nations, caught with ourselves in the net of life and time, fellow prisoners of the splendor and travail of the earth.” ― Henry Beston Want to see some video from our workshop? Check out the links below: Fladry demo Fladry relay race Fladry Q & A 13 Responses to “A Smarter Paradigm: Preventing Livestock Conflict in Wolf Country” Pamela Breindel July 18th, 2013 Hi. I’m interested in what you guys are doing for the wolves. I have a bachelors degree in environmental biology. I feel my life goal is to commit to one of the endangered animals from leaving this world. Wolves is one of those animals. I don’t have much money but I do have a car. I would love to volunteer. I live in Pennsylvania and so it seems all the workshops and things are out west. Can I still help. Please let me know. Sincerely, Pamela Breindel. lexie July 18th, 2013 Do you have any type of volunteer program? Richard Zeisse August 11th, 2013 I feel overwhelmed now that our government is planning to delist wolves. Please help. What can I do to help these beautiful sentient beings. Paul Lauenstein August 11th, 2013 It’s so good to see people figuring out ways to coexist with top predators. That’s what we have to do if we wish to sustain the vitality of ecosystems that sustain us. La Marca Monique August 11th, 2013 PROTECTION FOR ALL WOLVES? NO MORE TRAPPING THEM! Kathleen Michaels August 11th, 2013 I was so happy to hear what you all are doing. I love wolves, lived in Colorado 25 years, now live in Mn. I’m going to share you and email you where ever I can. Showing what is improving amongst the ranchers n farmers. A nice pick me up after hearing all the horrors going around about wolves. Keep the good works going and thank you all soooooooooo much. Kathleen Michaels n Wolf the cat. Tracy Alexandra August 11th, 2013 You’re ALL doing absolutely WONDERFUL WORK!!! You’re getting the msg across to many ranchers on how we can STOP this senseless killing! Thank you for ALL you do for animals!! Michael Siegle, Ph.D. August 11th, 2013 Congratulations on sharing your success. We can ask ranchers to use non-lethal deterrents, but showing and actually involving ranchers raises the success rates considerably. Tell me. Show me. Involve me. It is only through a partnership that non-lethal programs will be successful. Then ranchers and farmers can be further educated on the positive benefits of Wolves, and other keystone predators, they provide to their ecosystems. These programs are also important to the general public, as they too can help change attitudes. Given the opportunity, I would love to attend a workshop. Thank you. Despina M. Andrelus August 12th, 2013 “A righteous man regards the life of animals” – PROVERBS 12:10; “If you have men who will exclude any of God’s creatures from the shelter of compassion & pity, you will have men who will deal likewise with their fellow men” – FRANCIS OF ASSISI; “I hope to make people realize how totally helpless animals are, how dependent on us, trusting as a child must that we will be kind and take care of their needs…(They) are an obligation put on us, a responsibility we have no rights to neglect, nor to violate by cruelty….” – JAMES HARRIOT; “The greatness of a nation & its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated” – MAHATMA GANDHI. Christine Phelps August 14th, 2013 Thank-you all so very much for helpsing and educating people to defend the Wolves. They are God’s Creatures, and we need to protect them or they won’t be around for educating our Children and Grandchildren. I’m a member of Defenders for Wildlife and I try to support them . gloria taber August 15th, 2013 I wholeheartedly approve the use of non-lethal deterrents as far as protecting livestock from wolves. That way the ranchers don’t have to destroy wolves(who were there first anyway)in order to protect their livestock. This is what I’ve been saying all along. Ranchers and wolves can co-exist peacefully. Karen Uyeno August 23rd, 2013 I think fladry is wonderful! Keep up the good work! Vincent Cornish October 14th, 2013 Hello! I have Bachelor’s Science in Social Psychology (BSSP/HD) and have been very active in pro-wolf education and related activism and understand these specific social issues of segmented demographics and their related biases. I would like to coordinate fundraising events for the cause of wolf education and restraint from those who are “uneducated,” or simply money-loving, wolf haters. Please contact me. Post Your Comment Click here to cancel reply. Name (required) Mail (required) (will not be published) You May also be interested in I Was There It was a bitterly cold winter morning when the convoy departed down the remote Forest Service road near Salmon, Idaho. Decades after scientists first called for the restoration of wolves in the region, the first four wolves arrived in Idaho on January 14, 1995, thanks to the Endangered Species Act… Victory for Wild Bison in Montana! In a decision that the uninitiated would argue is a painful exercise in stating the obvious, a Montana court last week determined that the wild bison of Yellowstone, an animal that has roamed the continent for millennia, are indeed wild animals. Wolf Weekly Wrap-Up Population count for wolves in Northern Rockies; Should Northern Rockies wolves be relisted? Defenders requests immediate status review.